Importance of effective questions in the appraisal interview
Staff appraisals are far more than just a formality in personnel management.
They are an essential interface between managers and employees, laying the foundations for constructive cooperation and targeted personnel development.
But how do you make an appraisal interview really effective?
It’s not just the answers we receive, but also the questions we ask in the performance review.
The right set of questions can make the difference between a productive exchange and a conversation that only scratches the surface.
At teamecho, it’s always about asking the right questions. Whether it is about the Focus question set for meaningful work or strategies for employee retention the quality and depth of the questions have a decisive influence on the results.
In this article, we would therefore like to show you which questions really count in the performance review and how you can use them effectively. So that you not only listen, but also really understand.
Background: The depth of an effective appraisal interview
Before you dive deep into the art of conversation, it’s worth taking a look at the big picture.
What actually makes a good appraisal interview?
It’s not just the compliments or criticisms floating on the surface that make the difference.
It’s about asking the right questions in the performance review that promote a deeper understanding and a stronger connection between manager and employee.
An inspiring quote from Peter Drucker, the father of modern management, puts it in a nutshell:
„The most important thing in communication is listening to what is not being said.
The role of questions in the discussion process is twofold:
- Recognize and understand: Questions help to recognize and understand the employee’s thoughts, feelings and concerns. They allow you to listen beyond the words and grasp the underlying „why„.
- Commitment and development: By asking specific questions, you show interest and appreciation. This encourages employee commitment and opens doors for further development and growth.
At teamecho we have a variety of resources and special focus question sets which help managers to formulate and use effective questions in performance reviews. Take a look at our resources to dive deeper into this topic and prepare your list of questions for the next interview.
The basics: basic questions for every conversation
An effective appraisal interview always starts with the right questions. The basic questions – as simple as they may sound – are often the ones that have the greatest impact and open the door to deeper discussions. The buzzword „appraisal interview questions“ may be present in many companies, but it is the specific, targeted questions that really count.
The basics that should not be missing in any conversation include:
- How do you currently feel in your job?
- Where do you see your biggest challenges at the moment?
- What have been your most notable successes in recent months?
- How can the company support you better?
- Are there colleagues or processes with whom collaboration is particularly good or challenging?
These questions not only provide an insight into the employee’s well-being, but also encourage reflection on their own strengths, weaknesses and needs.
We know how important open dialog is for employee retention. We therefore recommend that you take a look at our whitepaper to find out more about the best practices for effective employee appraisals.
Another aspect you should consider is employee feedback. With the mood barometer from teamecho you can use topic-specific question sets to gain a deeper perspective on areas such as meaningful work or hybrid work and communication and communication.
Finally, it is important to emphasize that an appraisal interview is a two-way communication.
It’s not just about asking questions, but also about listening, understanding and acting.
So geht Mitarbeiterfeedback
Lerne, wie Mitarbeiter*innen-Feedback in der Praxis funktioniert. Beispiele inklusive! Schnapp dir jetzt unser Whitepaper.
Questions for your employees' self-reflection
An effective appraisal interview not only promotes communication between manager and employee, but also offers the employee a platform for self-reflection.
Self-reflection is the key to identifying strengths, weaknesses and opportunities for growth.
Let’s start with the question: „What are your professional goals for the next year?“
This question gives employees the opportunity to reflect on their ambitions, expectations and visions for their professional future.
Not only is it a good starting point for a more in-depth conversation about career development, it also leads to our mood barometer for employee retention which provides deep insights into employee satisfaction and retention.
The next point for consideration is:
„Where do you need more support or resources?“
This question guides the conversation towards resource allocation and support. If you want to understand how well your team is set up in terms of communication and collaboration, the Focus question set on hybrid work can be a valuable resource.
Finally: „What would you do differently in your job if you could?“
This question encourages creative problem solving and gives the employee the freedom to think about innovative approaches and improvements. Our numerous Focus question sets offer an in-depth look at various topics that could come up in employee appraisals.
In summary, self-reflection questions are essential in the performance review in order to develop a deeper understanding of the individual needs and goals of the team members. So you create a basis for a productive and beneficial conversation.
Questions about team dynamics and corporate culture
One of the key elements for the success of a company is team dynamics.
Harmonious cooperation can boost productivity and increase employee loyalty.
But as a manager, how can you ensure that the team works well together and that each individual feels valued?
This is exactly where targeted questions in the performance review come in. They offer the opportunity to delve deeper into the minds of team members and receive valuable feedback.
Start with the question: „How do you feel about working in a team?“
This question allows you to gain insight into daily interactions and potential points of conflict. You could go on to ask: „Are there any suggestions for improving the working atmosphere?“.
This gives employees the opportunity to provide constructive feedback and suggestions for optimizing the working atmosphere.
Finally, the question „How do you feel represented by the company values?“ is essential.
It shows you whether the values that the company stands for are actually being understood and lived by the employees.
Would you like to delve deeper into the topic and find out how to use questions optimally in appraisal interviews? Then take a look at the special Focus question sets from teamecho. Here you will find, for example, the Focus question set „Hybrid Work: Communication and collaboration“which offers you valuable suggestions for your next discussions.
In conclusion, it can be said that targeted questions in employee appraisals are essential in order to identify the strengths and weaknesses in the team and to constantly work on improvements. Take the opportunity to learn directly from your team!
Questions about further development and career planning
Planning for the future is a central element of the performance review.
Not only for the company itself, but also for the employee’s individual career path.
This raises the question: How can you, as a manager, help your employees to define and achieve their goals? This is exactly where targeted questions come into play in the performance review.
Firstly, it is important to clarify the need for further training. By asking questions such as: „What further training or courses would be of interest to you?“, you give your employees the opportunity to play an active role in their professional development.
Another important point is long-term career planning .
The question: „Where do you see yourself in the company in 5 years?“ can provide valuable insights. This will give you a better understanding of your team member’s ambitions and visions and how you can work together to realize them.
Finally, you should also find out how the company can support the employee in their career.
This is not just about further training, but also about mentoring, networking opportunities or special projects. A deeper insight into our employee retention strategies can help you with this and is here to find.
In conclusion, the right questions in the performance review are essential to set the course for a successful future together.
Feedback questions: Get the employee's opinion
Feedback is not only a valuable tool for professional development, it is also at the heart of an open and transparent corporate culture.
Certain questions are particularly important in employee appraisals in order to capture the perspective and feelings of the individual. The questions in the appraisal interview should therefore always revolve around the employee’s opinion and feedback.
- How can managers provide better support? Would you like team leaders or managers to get more actively involved in projects or leave more room for personal initiative? You may also be looking for more mentoring or training opportunities. The mood barometer, which focuses on leadership skills and the promotion of teamecho, helps to obtain a clear picture of what employees want.
- What tools or resources would make your day-to-day work easier? The right tools are not only essential in IT professions. Whether it's digital platforms, training resources or physical work tools, clear communication about what's missing is crucial.
- Do you have any suggestions for improving processes or procedures? Your daily experiences are worth their weight in gold. Where do you see potential for optimization? Which processes could be made more efficient?
A structured approach to collecting and analyzing this feedback can be achieved with teamecho’s tools, such as the intuitive dashboardcan be facilitated.
The central goal should always be to promote exchange between employees and managers and thus create a culture of continuous learning and improvement.
Whether you are an employee or a manager, open questions and honest feedback are the key to effective collaboration and a sustainable corporate culture.
The importance of listening
An effective performance review goes far beyond simply asking questions.
And while formulating precise „appraisal interview questions“ is crucial, the real magic should start the moment you hear the other person’s answer. This is the art of active listening.
Active listening means not only paying attention to the words being spoken, but also putting yourself in the speaker’s shoes and understanding the underlying emotions and concerns. It’s about creating a safe environment where employees feel free to share their thoughts and feelings. Here are some key elements of active listening:
- Full attention: Avoid distractions and concentrate fully on the speaker.
- Acknowledge by nodding or brief verbal approval: Show that you are present and committed.
- Avoid interruptions: Let the speaker finish without interrupting.
- Reflective feedback: Repeat in your own words what you have understood to ensure clarity.
- Open posture: Don’t cross your arms and keep eye contact.
But how can you train this skill? Teamecho offers a wealth of resourcesto help leaders strengthen their communication skills, including active listening.
For a deeper dive into the topic, read our white paper on employee retentionwhich presents strategies and techniques for optimizing employee appraisals.
Finally, it is important to emphasize that while questions are a starting point in an appraisal interview, the true potential of such a conversation is only unlocked through genuine, active listening.
By cultivating this skill, you can not only have better conversations, but also build deeper, trusting relationships with your team. And that is a priceless value in today’s business world.
Hier unser netter Newsletter
Alles rund um die Themen Employee Experience, Employer Branding, Change Management & Leadership. Regelmäßig, direkt in deinen Posteingang. Einfach abonnieren und genießen!
